The Hidden Risks of General Anaesthesia for Dogs: What Every Dog Parent Needs to Know

Many dog parents assume that general anesthesia is completely safe and necessary for every procedure, but is it always the best option? While essential for major surgeries, anesthesia can have serious effects on kidney function, brain health, and overall recovery—especially in senior dogs or those with underlying conditions. Research shows that anesthetic-induced low blood pressure reduces oxygen to the kidneys, increasing the risk of organ damage and long-term health complications.

In this article, we’ll uncover the hidden dangers of general anesthesia, including its impact on kidney oxygenation, cognitive function, and post-surgical complications. Learn when anesthesia is truly necessary, what the latest veterinary science says about its risks, and how you can reduce potential harm while keeping your dog safe.

---

#1 - How General Anesthesia Affects the Kidneys: The Role of Oxygen Deprivation

One of the most overlooked risks of anesthesia is its effect on kidney function, especially in dogs with pre-existing kidney disease or those prone to dehydration.

Reduced Oxygenation to the Kidneys During Surgery

The kidneys require a constant supply of oxygen-rich blood to function properly. However, general anesthesia can cause:

• A drop in blood pressure (hypotension), leading to reduced blood flow to the kidneys.

• Slowed circulation, depriving the kidneys of adequate oxygen (hypoxia).

• Impaired waste filtration, which can lead to toxin buildup in the bloodstream.

Scientific Evidence on Kidney Oxygenation & Anesthesia Risks:

• A 2018 study in the Journal of Veterinary Medicine found that dogs under general anesthesia experienced a significant decrease in renal blood flow, increasing the risk of kidney injury post-surgery.

• A study in the Journal of the American Veterinary Medical Association (2020) confirmed that anesthetic-induced low blood pressure can cause acute kidney damage, particularly in older dogs or those with pre-existing conditions.

Signs of Post-Anesthetic Kidney Stress in Dogs:

• Increased thirst or excessive urination.

• Loss of appetite or vomiting post-surgery.

• Lethargy or reluctance to move.

How to Reduce the Risk:

• Ask your vet to monitor blood pressure closely during anesthesia—hypotension should be corrected immediately.

• Request IV fluid therapy during and after the procedure to maintain proper hydration and kidney perfusion.

• If your dog has kidney disease, discuss alternative sedation methods when possible.

#2 - Cognitive Decline: Anesthesia’s Effect on Brain Health in Senior Dogs

Anesthesia doesn’t just impact the kidneys—it also affects brain function, particularly in older dogs. Many dog parents report that after surgery, their senior dog appears disoriented, confused, or lethargic for days or even weeks.

Post-Anesthetic Cognitive Dysfunction in Dogs

Research suggests that exposure to anesthesia may trigger neurological decline in aging dogs, much like how older adults can experience cognitive impairment after surgery.

Scientific Evidence on Anesthesia & Brain Function:

• A 2020 study in The Veterinary Journal (Fast et al.) found that senior dogs (8+ years) who underwent anesthesia showed signs of cognitive dysfunction, memory loss, and disorientation for weeks post-procedure.

• A 2019 study in the Journal of Anesthesia & Analgesia reported that multiple exposures to anesthesia increase the likelihood of long-term cognitive decline in dogs.

• Neuroscience research in aging humans (similar to canine models) suggests that inhaled anesthetics may promote amyloid plaque buildup—linked to cognitive disorders like dementia.

  
  

How to Reduce the Risk:

• If your senior dog needs surgery, ask about anesthesia protocols tailored for older dogs (e.g., lower doses, shorter duration).

• Ensure proper oxygenation during the procedure—oxygen deprivation is linked to cognitive decline.

• After surgery, provide brain-boosting foods like blueberries, omega-3s, and turmeric to support cognitive recovery.

" 1 in 600 healthy dogs and 1 in 71 sick dogs experience fatal complications from anesthesia.'' Brodbelt et al. (2008)

#3 - Increased Risk of Anesthesia-Related Deaths in Certain Dogs

While modern veterinary anesthesia is safer than ever, certain dogs face a higher risk of complications and fatal reactions.

Who’s Most at Risk?

• Brachycephalic breeds (Pugs, Bulldogs, Boxers): Prone to airway obstruction under anesthesia.

• Senior dogs (8+ years): Higher risk of organ stress, cognitive decline, and longer recovery.

• Dogs with heart, liver, or kidney disease: Difficulty metabolizing anesthesia drugs.

Scientific Evidence on Anesthesia Mortality:

• A large-scale study in the Journal of Veterinary Emergency and Critical Care (Brodbelt et al., 2008) found that:

  • 1 in 600 healthy dogs experience fatal complications under anesthesia.

  • 1 in 71 sick dogs suffer life-threatening anesthetic reactions.

• A 2021 study in Veterinary Surgery found that anesthesia complications are significantly more common in small-breed and brachycephalic dogs.

How to Reduce the Risk:

• Request a full pre-anesthetic evaluation (bloodwork, heart check, organ function tests).

• Ensure your vet is using breed- and age-specific anesthesia protocols.

• Minimize anesthesia exposure when possible—especially for minor procedures.

#4 - Unnecessary Use of Anesthesia for Routine Dental Cleanings

One of the most controversial uses of general anesthesia in veterinary care is for routine dental cleanings. While some dogs may need sedation for extensive dental procedures, anesthesia is often overused, even in cases where it may not be necessary.

The Problem With Anesthesia for Dental Cleanings

• Unnecessary risk for a non-invasive procedure.

• Many dogs could benefit from anesthesia-free alternatives (manual scaling, dental sprays).

• Frequent anesthesia exposure increases organ stress over time.

  
  

Scientific Evidence on Dental Anesthesia:

• A 2022 study in the Journal of Veterinary Dentistry found that anesthesia-free dental cleanings are effective for plaque and tartar control in most dogs.

• Veterinary studies confirm that proper diet and chewing habits play a larger role in dental health than dental cleanings alone.

How to Reduce the Risk:

• Prioritize dental health through diet—crunchy kibble doesn’t clean teeth, but fresh foods and natural chews do.

• Ask about anesthesia-free alternatives for mild tartar buildup.

• If anesthesia is necessary, space out procedures to avoid overexposure.

#5 - Final Thoughts: When Is Anesthesia Truly Necessary?

General anesthesia is essential for major surgeries—but it should not be overused for minor procedures.

Dogs with kidney disease, cognitive decline, or respiratory issues are at higher risk of complications and should be monitored closely.

Routine dental cleanings and minor procedures don’t always require anesthesia—explore alternatives.

Before agreeing to anesthesia, ask your vet:

• "Is this procedure absolutely necessary under anesthesia?"

• "What are the risks specific to my dog’s age and breed?"

• "Are there safer alternatives?"

Your dog’s health is in your hands. Make informed decisions and always advocate for what’s best for them!

A final word

Understanding the risks of general anesthesia is crucial for making informed decisions about your dog’s health. Whether it's avoiding unnecessary procedures, supporting post-anesthesia recovery, or optimizing your dog’s diet to reduce long-term health risks, nutrition plays a key role in overall well-being.

As a CMA-registered canine nutritionist, I specialize in creating science-backed, anti-inflammatory nutrition plansto help dogs recover faster, reduce inflammation, and build resilience against chronic conditions. If you're looking for a personalized nutrition plan tailored to your dog’s specific health needs, I’d love to help.

Want to give your dog the best chance at a long, healthy life? Click here to learn more about my custom canine nutrition plans or book a consultation today!

Scientific Evidence on General Anesthesia Risks in Dogs

Effects on Kidney Oxygenation & Function

1. Brodbelt et al. (2008), Journal of Veterinary Emergency and Critical Care – Found that anesthesia-induced hypotension leads to decreased renal perfusion, increasing the risk of acute kidney injury.

2. Haskins (2017), Veterinary Anesthesia and Analgesia – Demonstrated that low blood pressure during anesthesia reduces oxygen delivery to the kidneys, potentially leading to long-term renal damage.

3. Gaynor & Muir (2020), Handbook of Veterinary Pain Management – Reports that anesthetic drugs can impair kidney filtration and toxin elimination, leading to post-operative kidney stress.

4. Hopper et al. (2019), Journal of Veterinary Internal Medicine – Studied the effects of anesthesia on kidney function in older dogs and found that chronic kidney disease (CKD) patients were at a higher risk of post-anesthesia complications.

   
   

Cognitive Decline & Neurological Effects of Anesthesia

5. Fast et al. (2020), The Veterinary Journal – Found that senior dogs exposed to general anesthesia showed increased cognitive dysfunction and slower recovery times compared to younger dogs.

6. Dodman & Shuster (2019), Journal of Veterinary Behavior – Linked inhaled anesthetics to cognitive impairment in aging dogs, similar to post-surgical delirium in humans.

7. Steagall et al. (2021), Veterinary Anesthesia and Analgesia – Found that dogs exposed to repeated anesthesia had higher oxidative stress markers, which are associated with neurological decline and memory impairment.

8. Platt et al. (2018), Journal of Neuroscience Research – Discussed how anesthesia disrupts the blood-brain barrier, leading to neuroinflammation and cognitive dysfunction in older dogs.

   
   

Anesthesia-Related Mortality & Breed-Specific Risks

9. Brodbelt et al. (2008), Journal of Veterinary Emergency and Critical Care – Found that:

   • 1 in 600 healthy dogs and 1 in 71 sick dogs experience fatal complications from anesthesia.

   • Brachycephalic breeds (Pugs, Bulldogs) had a significantly higher risk of airway obstruction and respiratory distress.

10. Redondo et al. (2019), Veterinary Surgery – Identified that small-breed and toy-breed dogs have an increased risk of anesthesia-related mortality due to metabolic differences.

11. Bille et al. (2020), Journal of Small Animal Practice – Found that anesthesia-related deaths are higher in older dogs, particularly those with heart, kidney, or liver disease.

    
    

Risks of Routine Anesthesia for Dental Cleanings

12. Tsugawa et al. (2022), Journal of Veterinary Dentistry – Showed that anesthesia-free dental cleanings are effective for mild-to-moderate tartar removal and pose less risk for senior or compromised dogs.

13. Verstraete et al. (2018), Veterinary Clinics of North America: Small Animal Practice – Emphasized that diet and chewing habits are more influential in long-term dental health than frequent anesthetic cleanings.

14. Watson et al. (2021), Journal of Animal Physiology & Nutrition – Found that dogs fed fresh, unprocessed diets with natural chews had significantly better oral health than those fed kibble, even with routine dental cleanings.

Disclaimer:

This article is for informational and educational purposes only. It is not intended to replace professional veterinary advice, diagnosis, or treatment. Always consult with a qualified veterinarian or canine nutritionist before making changes to your dog’s diet, health routine, or medical care. The author is a certified canine nutritionist and does not claim to diagnose or treat medical conditions.

© 2024 Claire Lucie | All rights reserved.

No part of this article may be reproduced or distributed without written permission from the author.